When you do a rebrand, what do you do with the retired mark? It’s a question that has plagued trademark holders for years. The Lanham Act defines abandonment as discontinuation of use with intent not to resume, and three consecutive years of nonuse creates a rebuttable presumption of abandonment. 15 U.S.C. § 1127. If you are a holder of a retired trademark, what options do you have to maintain control over its use?
Two news stories last week put the same question in front of trademark counsel from opposite angles. On one side of the coin, the Washington Commanders recently added a throwback merchandise line featuring the retired Redskins name and helmet logo, honoring former stars Art Monk, Darrell Green, and the late Sean Taylor. A team spokesperson said that the sale is required “to keep the old trademarks in commercial use to keep control of them.” On the flip side, a Virginia startup called Operation Bluebird launched a social media platform called Twitter.now, running on the legal theory that X Corp. abandoned the Twitter marks when it rebranded in 2023. One brand owner is running the maintenance drill, and the other is finding out what happens when you skip it.
The Commanders and the maintenance playbook
The Commanders retired the Redskins name and logo in 2020, after decades of criticism from Native American advocates who identified the term as a racial slur. The retirement followed sustained pressure from sponsors, players, tribal nations, and civil rights organizations, and the team publicly committed to moving away from the mark. Five years later, the same team is putting the mark back on shirts in limited quantities, and they are explaining the move as trademark maintenance.
The strategy is legally reasonable. Continuous commercial use, even in modest volumes, is the standard defense against a presumption of abandonment. Nostalgia and throwback lines featuring retired players and historical uniforms have generally survived scrutiny in the sports context. Accordingly, the Commanders’ approach fits the mainstream maintenance model.
The strategy also comes with risks. Courts distinguish bona fide commercial use from token use engineered only to preserve rights. In Silverman v. CBS Inc., 870 F.2d 40 (2d Cir. 1989), the Second Circuit held that CBS’s minimal activity relating to the Amos ’n’ Andy marks did not defeat abandonment, even where the network retained residual public recognition. Volume, continuity, and good-faith commercial purpose all matter. A one-off throwback drop five years into a retirement is not the same as an ongoing merchandise program.
But none of this addresses the potential reputational risk with take the standard maintenance approach in this case. The Association on American Indian Affairs objected to the merchandise sales within a day of launch, creating a potential strategic problem for the brand. The mark was retired because it caused harm to a community that had been asking for its retirement for decades. Reintroducing it, even in limited volumes and even framed as legal housekeeping, invites the same criticism the retirement was designed to resolve. Trademark maintenance does not exist in a vacuum. For that reason, a rebrand advisory conversation should include a candid discussion of whether the legacy mark is worth preserving at all. Notably, the “cost” of preservation may not be worth it in the end.
X Corp. and the residual-goodwill gamble
X Corp. did not run this play. As many will recall, in July 2023, Elon Musk rebranded Twitter to X, removed the bird logo, redirected twitter.com to x.com, and phased out “tweet” and “retweet.” Musk’s team also publicly announced that the company would “bid adieu to the Twitter brand.” By July 2026, three consecutive years of nonuse had elapsed.
Anticipating the eventual abandonment, in December 2025, Operation Bluebird filed a 105-page cancellation petition with the USPTO, seeking to void the Twitter and Tweet registrations. Shortly after, X filed a federal lawsuit in Delaware, seeking an injunction to prevent the startup from operating under the Twitter name. At an April 2026 hearing in X Corp. v. Operation Bluebird, the Court stated from the bench that X appeared to have abandoned its claims to “Tweet,” the bird logo, and even potentially to the word “Twitter.”
X Corp.’s theory was residual goodwill. The doctrine holds that a rebranded owner can still assert common-law rights where the public continues to associate the old mark with the owner. See Ferrari S.p.A. Esercizio Fabbriche Automobili e Corse v. McBurnie, 11 U.S.P.Q.2d 1843 (S.D. Cal. 1989). While residual goodwill legally exists, it is also, obviously, weaker than a registration paired with active use. For example, the doctrine did not save the MLB in Major League Baseball Properties, Inc. v. Sed Non Olet Denarius, Ltd., 817 F. Supp. 1103 (S.D.N.Y. 1993), where a Brooklyn restaurant successfully argued that decades of nonuse extinguished trademark rights in “The Brooklyn Dodger” name.
On September 3, 2026, the District Court issued a written memorandum opinion that made those preliminary observations more concrete. X Corp. v. Operation Bluebird, Inc., No. 25-cv-1510 (D. Del. Sept. 3, 2026). The Court granted X Corp’s motion for a preliminary injunction in part and denied it in part, splitting the TWITTER Marks into two categories with different outcomes.
The District Court found that the word marks survived, largely based on X Corp.’s Apple App Store listing, which described the platform as “Welcome to X (formerly known as Twitter), your trusted digital town square.” The Court found this constituted bona fide use of the eight Twitter-formative marks. The Court further held that the “formerly known as Twitter” parenthetical identified and distinguished the source of the service and linked the acquired platform to its rebranded successor. The Court relied on Wells Fargo & Co. v. ABD Ins. & Fin. Servs., 758 F.3d 1069 (9th Cir. 2014), and Perry v. H.J. Heinz Co. Brands, L.L.C., 994 F.3d 466, 475 (5th Cir. 2021), among other cases for the proposition that “even minor or sporadic good faith uses of a mark will defeat the defense of abandonment.” Bluebird’s argument that the parenthetical was too small, or too textual, to count as trademark use found no support in the case law and none in the ruling.
The District Court also held, however, that the Tweet mark and Bird logo did not survive. Neither appeared in the App Store listing, and neither appeared on x.com. X Corp.’s counsel conceded at the April hearing that the Bird logo and “Tweet” are “nowhere to be found” on the platform’s home page. X Corp. offered several theories of continued use, all of which were rejected by the Court. Remnant web pages that X Corp. had never taken down were, in the Court’s words, “the type of token and residual use of a mark that the Lanham Act does not consider a bona fide use in commerce.” See Specht v. Google Inc., 758 F. Supp. 2d 570, 593 (N.D. Ill. 2010), aff’d, 747 F.3d 929 (7th Cir. 2014). Legacy Facebook and Instagram accounts under the Twitter name had also gone unused since 2021 and 2022. And X Corp.’s brand-use guidelines controlled the manner and form of third-party display but not the nature or quality of any third party’s goods or services, as required under 15 U.S.C. § 1055.
Musk’s July 2023 statements did most of the intent work for the Court. “And soon we shall bid adieu to the twitter brand and, gradually, all the birds.” “We’re cutting the Twitter logo off the building with blow torches.” The Court found those pre-litigation pronouncements “far more probative” than the contrary testimony X Corp.’s Legal Director offered at the April hearing. Executive communications, once made, become record evidence.
What do these scenarios tell us about advising a client through a rebrand?
Three lessons emerge, and they operate together.
The first is that the decision about whether the legacy mark carries residual value worth preserving belongs at the front end of the rebrand conversation, not two years in when someone notices the three-year clock. If the answer is yes, the client needs a real maintenance program built into the rebrand plan. The reassuring news from X Corp. v. Operation Bluebird is that the bar for bona fide use is not enormous. A single parenthetical on an app store listing was enough to save the Twitter word marks. The Perry standard the Court cited, that “even minor or sporadic good faith uses of a mark will defeat the defense of abandonment,” is friendly ground for clients who plan ahead.
The second lesson is that if the client wants to preserve rights in a legacy logo, tagline, or product name, the maintenance program has to actually touch each mark the client cares about. Residual goodwill is a backstop, not a strategy. The District Court’s split ruling in Operation Bluebird is instructive. X Corp. said “formerly known as Twitter” in one commercial listing, and the word marks survived. X Corp. said nothing about “Tweet” or the Bird logo anywhere current consumers would see, and those marks were lost. A rebrand asset inventory should list every mark the client wants to preserve, and the maintenance plan should tie a specific, current, commercial use to each of them. The Commanders’ throwback line, on the other hand, puts a name and a logo on the same shirt, and it likely was not an accident.
Third, executive communications during a rebrand are trademark evidence. Musk’s public statements did more damage to X Corp.’s position on the Tweet mark and Bird logo than Bluebird’s briefing did. “We are saying goodbye to the birds,” is the sentence a District Court will quote back in the abandonment ruling. Marketing, communications, and legal need to be on the same page as the executive team before announcements about a rebrand are made.
There is also a category of legacy mark that should not be preserved. Some marks carry reputational costs that no amount of trademark work can offset. In light of the criticism the Commanders drew within twenty-four hours of the throwback launch, the cleaner path for some clients is a full and public retirement, with a corresponding acceptance that the mark is gone.
A rebrand is a trademark decision and a communications decision at the same time. The Commanders are testing whether limited throwback sales will satisfy a court that wants to see bona fide commercial use. X Corp.’s strategy was partially effective: the word marks survived on the strength of a parenthetical in advertising and the Tweet mark and Bird logo are gone. Both outcomes matter for every brand owner who has ever considered walking away from a legacy mark.